About MaxDiff Clustering
Within populations of survey respondents are groups of like-minded people. These groups, or “clusters,” can be determined by how similar each respondent’s most preferred features are. By clustering each respondent based on their individual utility for each attribute, we can determine subpopulations and what demographics make up these subpopulations.
Preparing a Survey for Clustering
Before you can use MaxDiff clustering, you have to make sure that the survey of your MaxDiff Project is asking the right questions. This means you need to set up certain features before you collect data.
Block 1, with all its demographic questions, is located right above the MaxDiff block, although you can move it as desired.
You can only conduct MaxDiff clustering using Single-Select Multiple Choice questions. This is because they offer a finite selection of choices that can be easily analyzed. You can also use some survey metadata, such as Start Date, IP Address, Recipient Information, and more.
- Demographics: Ask about basic descriptive information, such as age, income bracket, race, or gender.
- Behavior: Ask how customers interact with your brand and your products, or about behaviors that may relate to their purchasing behavior. For example, you can ask how often the customer goes shopping.
- Operational Data: This is information such as time spent on your website, or an employee’s tenure in your company.
- Question Formats: Format questions about behaviors and beliefs as scales. The range on a scale can help us understand what scale points are correlated and therefore roughly in the same cluster; Yes/No and single-select questions are not as useful for cluster analysis.
Example: If you ask “What kind of shopper are you?” and give the options “Prefer shopping at malls”, “Prefer shopping online”, and “Prefer shopping at boutiques”, the clustering algorithm will want to divide respondents into three groups, one for each answer. If you instead asked those as a series of questions (e.g., “Do you like shopping at malls?”) with responses 1 through 7, the clustering algorithm will do a better job at really discerning what separates different shoppers from each other.
Clustering can be found in the MaxDiff Clustering section of the Reports tab.
To make data appear the first time, you may need to click Refresh in the MaxDiff Analysis section, instead.
Adjusting Demographics Used in Clustering
By default, MaxDiff clustering will use every Multiple Choice survey question you have made. However, you don’t have to use every question if you don’t want to, and you can add and remove content to see what different clusters this feature recommends to you.
In the box to the right of the Cluster Details header, click the X on a question to remove it from cluster analysis. Removing a question does not cause the clusters to recalculate.
In the box to the right of the Cluster Details header, click the dropdown arrow. Then select the questions you’d like to add back to the clusters.
Once you’ve collected enough data and refreshed your MaxDiff clustering page, this feature will recommend clusters to you. These clusters are determined based on how similar the respondents’ most preferred features are. Their individual utility for each attribute is calculated, and then the demographics common amongst these clusters are highlighted so you can gain a better understanding of how different populations prefer your products.
Highlight a cluster in the top graph to learn more about this cluster. Click it to open the Cluster Details below.
- Summary: The top bar of the Cluster Details gives a quick summary of the most salient details, primarily which cluster it is, the statistical significance of the cluster, how the respondents generally answered the demographic questions, how many responses are in this cluster, and the percent of responses this cluster applies to. You can also click this part to expand and collapse the rest of the information.
Example: In Cluster 1 pictured here, the responses tend to be from people who own their own apartment. 4 respondents generally fit this pattern, which is 80% of the entire data set. This is a very small data set, so decisions likely should not be made based on these results. This is also indicated by the cluster’s weak strength.
- Demographics: A series of breakdown bars displaying how the members of this cluster responded to the demographic questions. Each breakdown bar is labeled by the response that is most highly correlated to the utility scores for the most preferred features, however, you’ll see that people in a cluster will vary in how they answered.
Example: Cluster 1’s annual income is listed as “$20,000 – $29,000.” However, this isn’t the most common annual income for this cluster, as we can see the bar for “$70,000 – $79,000” at the end is much longer. That’s because those who have a lower income are simply more likely to have valued Reasonable prices, Durability, and so on, than those in the cluster who have a higher annual income.
- Top Five Features: These are the five features the members of the cluster were most likely to indicate as their most preferred when selecting features from a list. The demographics highlighted have high utility scores for the attributes chosen here.
- Preview Analysis: Click this button to see the MaxDiff Analysis report for this cluster’s data, only.
Determining Cluster Strength
Qualtrics uses a metric called silhouette scoring to determine the strength of each cluster. This score produces a value between 0 and 1 which determines how closely clustered the respondents are. We use the following table to convert from silhouette score to cluster strength:
|Correlation Score||Relationship Strength||Cluster Strength Label|
|0.71 to 1.0||Very strong relationship||Strong|
|0.51 to 0.70||Somewhat strong relationship||Somewhat strong|
|0.26 to 0.50||Somewhat weak relationship||Somewhat weak|
|0 to 0.25||No significant relationship||Weak|
Applying Clusters to Reports
Clusters can be applied to the MaxDiff Analysis report so that you can see more specific details about how respondents in this cluster evaluated the attributes presented to them.
While in the MaxDiff Analysis section of the Reports tab, select a cluster from the Segments dropdown in the upper-left.
You can also select Preview Analysis when you have a cluster selected in the MaxDiff Clustering section of the Reports tab.